inquesta-forensic-director-author-Rob-Miller

By Rob Miller

Forensic accountant and expert witness specialising in offering expertise on POCA, cryptocurrency, and financial dispute matters.

Updated November 2026 | 15 min read time

A confiscation order defence tests the two figures that decide what you actually pay: the prosecution’s benefit figure and your available amount. A forensic accountant independently tests whether those figures are supported by the evidence. Proving that either is wrong requires detailed financial evidence, not just a compelling argument.

Confiscation orders under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 are among the most powerful tools available to the state for stripping a convicted defendant of assets. However, the figures the prosecution puts forward can be higher than the law actually supports, and a confiscation order defence is how they are challenged.

What is a Confiscation Order Under the Proceeds of Crime Act?

A confiscation order defence is the process of contesting how much the court orders you to pay after conviction. It contests two figures: what the prosecution says you gained from crime (the benefit), and what you can actually realise from your assets (the available amount). The order is made in the lower of the two, so the figure that matters for the order is whichever is lower. The benefit figure still matters later, because it caps any increase under section 22.

A confiscation order is made by the Crown Court under Part 2 of the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002, always after conviction, in cases involving financial gain such as fraud, trafficking, or money laundering. Defendants can face figures that are higher than the evidence supports, through assumptions applied too broadly or financial assessments that miss what is really recoverable. Both are contestable, and contesting them is the core of any POCA defence at the confiscation stage. For how the process runs from conviction to final order, see my guide to the POCA confiscation timetable.

Need Forensic Accounting Expertise?

How do you Challenge the Prosecution’s Benefit Figure?

In a confiscation order defence, you challenge the prosecution’s benefit figure by testing what the defendant actually obtained, item by item, against the bank records and accounts. Benefit is the value of the property the defendant obtained, not their profit: the House of Lords confirmed in R v May [2008] UKHL 28 that there is no general deduction for costs.

The figure can still be wrong in several ways. One of the most common overstatements I see is a business’s whole turnover being treated as the defendant’s benefit. Whether that is right depends on what the defendant personally obtained, and on three limits the courts have set.

First, the Supreme Court held in R v Waya [2012] UKSC 51 that a confiscation order must be proportionate. That doesn’t mean confiscating turnover is always disproportionate. It applies in specific situations: where the property has been restored to the loser, or, as the Court of Appeal found in R v Sale [2013] EWCA Crim 1306, where the defendant supplied genuine goods or services in return for the money.

That limit is narrow. In R v King [2014] EWCA Crim 621, the Court of Appeal upheld an order for the full takings of a car dealer who had passed off trade sales as private ones, because the business itself depended on the deception.

Second, VAT the defendant has already accounted for to HMRC is deducted, following R v Harvey [2015] UKSC 73. Third, money paid to a company isn’t automatically the director’s benefit just because they controlled the company and committed the offence. The court has to find that the director personally obtained it.

The second recurring problem is criminal lifestyle assumptions under section 10 including money that has a provable legitimate source, like an inheritance, a remortgage, or a business loan, simply because it landed within the six-year window.

Both can be contested, which will hinge on following the actual flow of money through the bank records and accounts rather than accepting the prosecution’s figure at face value.

Engaging a forensic accountant to review the financial records in this way is what allows a confiscation order defence to argue for a reduced benefit figure. Remember, a lower benefit figure lowers the ceiling on the whole order.

question-mark-written-by-hand-on-a-blackboard

What is the “Available Amount” and How is it Challenged?

The available amount is the value of everything the defendant holds, plus any tainted gifts. Where the benefit figure is higher, the available amount is the figure the order is actually made in. After the benefit figure is set, the court assesses the available amount: the value of assets the defendant can actually realise if sold. If that figure is lower than the benefit figure, the order should be set at the available amount.

A benefit figure far above what the defendant holds still matters. The shortfall can be pursued under section 22 if the defendant’s means improve, and the benefit figure caps any increase. The order can only be enforced against real, realisable assets. The prosecution’s assessment of the available amount can be wrong where it treats jointly held or third-party assets as though they belong entirely to the defendant.

The family home is the classic example: where a spouse has a genuine beneficial interest, that share is not the defendants to surrender, and it takes proper valuation and evidence of contributions to establish it. The mechanism for deciding a third party’s share is set out in my guide to section 10A and third-party rights.

The other frequent issue I see concerns money the defendant has put into a company and the question of whether it was a genuine loan the company owes back, or simply their own capital. That distinction changes the realisable figure, and it’s exactly the kind of issue that needs a forensic accountant’s analysis, not just an assertion from one side or the other.

To learn how the benefit and available figures are calculated in detail, see my guide to how the POCA benefit figure is calculated.

How Does a Benefit Figure Get Reduced?

Take a hypothetical that reflects the pattern of these cases. 

Take a hypothetical that reflects the pattern of many confiscation order defence cases.

A company director is convicted of an offence connected to their business, and the prosecution’s section 16 statement puts the benefit as the total turnover that passed through the company over the relevant period. In this example, the figure is several hundred thousand pounds. On the face of it, that is what the defendant is liable for, right?

On examination, three questions come up. Was the money obtained by the director personally, or by the company? How much of it was VAT already paid over to HMRC? And did the company supply genuine goods or services in return, which goes to whether an order for the full amount would be proportionate?

Answering those questions from the bank records, the VAT returns and the company’s accounts is what tests whether the headline figure is right, and what a proportionate figure would be. It is the same analysis that sits behind calculating the benefit figure correctly in the first place, and it often shows how much money is actually available to recover.

black-gift-with-bow-tainted-gift

How do you Rebut a Criminal Lifestyle Assumption?

You rebut a criminal lifestyle assumption by proving, on the balance of probabilities, that specific property or income came from a legitimate source, or by showing that applying the assumption would create a serious risk of injustice.

Since 29 June 2026, the court only decides whether the defendant has a criminal lifestyle if the prosecutor asks it to. Under section 75 there are three tests:

  • The offence is listed in Schedule 2 (for example drug trafficking or money laundering).
  • The offence is part of a course of criminal activity and the benefit is at least £5,000.
  • The offence was committed over at least six months and the benefit is at least £5,000.

If the court finds a criminal lifestyle, section 10 demands that four assumptions be made when calculating benefit:

  • Any property transferred to the defendant in the six years before proceedings began was obtained through criminal conduct.
  • Any property held after the date of conviction was obtained through criminal conduct.
  • Any expenditure in the six years before proceedings was met from the proceeds of crime.
  • Any property obtained is held free of other interests. This means that its full value counts against the defendant.

The assumptions apply unless shown to be incorrect, or unless there would be a serious risk of injustice (section 10(6)). Since June 2026, section 10(6A) also requires the court to weigh the defendant’s explanation for any evidence they can no longer produce.

Rebutting them comes down to depth of records: bank statements, pay slips, loan and sale documents that trace a legitimate origin for the money the prosecution is treating as criminal. Where the records no longer exist, a documented reason why is now evidence the court has to consider.

What Changed for Confiscation Order Defence in June 2026?

The Crime and Policing Act 2026 changed several parts of confiscation from 29 June 2026:

  • The court only decides criminal lifestyle if the prosecutor asks.
  • A course of criminal activity now needs the offence plus two others in the current proceedings, down from three, and includes conduct the defendant intended to benefit from. The intended-benefit change doesn’t apply to conduct that took place wholly or partly before 29 June 2026.
  • Hidden property findings are now statutory under section 9A, and the court must consider other explanations for the gap before adding a figure for hidden assets.
    A restraint order now needs a real risk that the property will be dissipated.

Common Questions I’m Asked in Confiscation Order Defence Cases

Dealing with confiscation defence cases as a forensic accountant often leads to the same questions. Questions mainly surrounding hidden or frozen assets, tainted gifts, and whether a confiscation order can be increased years after it was made. Here is my stance on each:

What happens with hidden asset allegations?

The defendant has to show the court that their available amount is less than the benefit figure. If the court doesn’t accept their evidence, it can infer that assets are hidden, and since June 2026 section 9A requires it to put a value on hidden property and add it to the available amount, after first considering other explanations such as money spent or assets that have fallen in value.

In a confiscation order defence, answering that allegation requires transparent, evidenced disclosure: in the section 18 statement, if the court orders one, and in the section 17 response to the prosecution’s statement.

A forensic accountant’s role here is to verify and evidence the disclosed position, and to show where the money actually went.

For more details, see my guide to identifying hidden assets under POCA.

Can you Challenge Tainted Gifts?

Yes. A tainted gift is property the defendant gave away, or transferred for significantly less than it was worth. Under sections 77 and 78, its value is added to the available amount.

In a lifestyle case, any gift made after the relevant day (the start of the six-year period) is tainted, whatever the source of the money. In other cases, a gift is tainted if it was made after the date of the offence.

The court interprets the word “gift” broadly. Property sold below value, written-off debts, assets transferred into joint names without fair payment can all qualify. Where something was sold for significantly less than it was worth, the gift is the shortfall from market value.

The defence is evidential: showing the transfer was made for full value, or falls outside the relevant period.

For more information about challenging tainted gift assumptions, see my guide to tainted gifts and POCA.

What about Restraint Orders Freezing Your Assets?

A restraint order under section 41 of POCA freezes a defendant’s assets while an investigation or prosecution is ongoing. This often takes place before any charge has been brought, and the outcome can be devastating: bank accounts locked, property unsaleable, and day-to-day finances paralysed at the very point someone most needs resources to defend themselves. Orders normally allow reasonable living expenses, and since 29 June 2026 the court must be satisfied there is a real risk the property will be dissipated before it makes one.

A restraint order can be challenged by demonstrating the legitimate origin and ownership of the assets it has caught, and varied to allow for the defendant’s actual living costs.

There is also a point most guides miss: where a restraint order is applied for without notice, the prosecution is under a strict duty of candour: an obligation to put everything relevant before the judge, including anything that weakens its own case. Where that duty hasn’t been met, the order itself is open to challenge. Accurate tracing of assets, especially in complex cases involving cryptocurrency or offshore accounts, is often what makes that argument possible.

Can the Order be Increased Later? (Section 22)

Yes. Under section 22, the prosecution can apply to increase a confiscation order if the defendant’s available assets grow after the order is made, up to the benefit figure.

What surprises most defendants is how far this reaches: a section 22 application can capture wealth earned entirely legitimately, even years after the sentence has been served. The Supreme Court confirmed in Re Peacock [2012] UKSC 5 that legitimately acquired assets are caught.

The court has a discretion to make whatever order it believes is just, taking into account the time that has passed, the nature of the new asset and the effect on the defendant. A forensic accountant’s part is the evidence behind that argument: what the new asset is really worth, and how much of it is the defendant’s.

What if you Can’t Pay the Confiscation Order?

f you can’t pay a confiscation order by the deadline, you can apply for more time or, where you genuinely cannot pay, apply to the Crown Court under section 23 to vary the order downward. Payment is due when the order is made unless the court grants an extension, up to a maximum of six months in total. Failing to pay risks a default prison sentence, served on top of the original sentence, with the debt plus interest still standing afterwards.

Default terms run to the value of the order:

  • Orders of £10,000 or less: up to six months.
  • Orders over £10,000 and up to £500,000: up to five years.
  • Orders over £500,000 and up to £1 million: up to seven years.
  • Orders over £1 million: up to 14 years.

For more information on this, see my guide to what happens if you can’t pay a POCA confiscation order.

Additional Common Questions on Confiscation Order Defence

Can a confiscation order be quashed? Yes. A confiscation order can be quashed or reduced on appeal, or through the Criminal Cases Review Commission, if it was wrongly imposed or the benefit was miscalculated. The CCRC has referred cases where the order was based on an incorrect benefit figure or a wrongly applied assumption.

What is the difference between confiscation and forfeiture? A confiscation order is a personal debt for the value of the benefit from crime, paid from any of the defendant’s assets. A forfeiture order is directed at a specific item of property connected to the offence. They are different mechanisms that can apply to the same case.

Can you appeal a confiscation order? Yes. A defendant can appeal a confiscation order, commonly on the basis that the benefit figure was overstated or the criminal lifestyle classification was wrong. An appeal needs leave from the Court of Appeal, and notice must usually be given within 28 days. Appeals are normally decided on the material that was before the Crown Court; new evidence is only admitted if it meets the test in section 23 of the Criminal Appeal Act 1968. That is why the forensic analysis needs to be done before the confiscation hearing.

Do you need a solicitor and a forensic accountant for a confiscation order defence? Usually both, in distinct roles. The solicitor runs the legal defence and gives the confiscation order legal advice; the forensic accountant produces the independent financial analysis, on the benefit and available-amount figures, that the legal argument is built on. The two work together, and the accountant’s report is what gives the numbers weight in court.

How Does a Forensic Accountant Strengthen a Confiscation Defence?

The earlier a forensic accountant is involved as a confiscation defence expert, the more can be done. This is because the figures are easier to test before they harden into an agreed position. The core contribution is turning assertions into evidence: testing the benefit figure, evidencing the true available amount, and testing each assumption against properly documented sources.

In practice that means three things:

  1. Engaging early, so the financial analysis is ready when the defence responds to the section 16 statement, rather than rushed against a deadline.
  2. Testing the assumptions, rather than accepting valuations at face value. This shows whether a benefit figure has been inflated by gross-for-net treatment or over-broad lifestyle assumptions.
  3. Evidencing the available amount: proper valuations, third-party interests, and the loan-versus-capital questions that move the realisable figure.

Since June 2026 the court sets the confiscation timetable at sentencing. Working to that timetable, with the financial analysis done thoroughly, gives the court figures it can rely on.

How can Inquesta Forensic Help With a Confiscation Order Defence?

Inquesta Forensic is led by Rob Miller, a chartered accountant (FCA), Practising Member of the Academy of Experts (MAE), and Certified Cryptocurrency Investigator (CCI), instructed as an expert witness in POCA confiscation proceedings.

The difference in a confiscation order defence is rarely the legal argument alone. It’s more likely to revolve around whether the numbers behind it stack up. Everything in this guide, from testing an inflated benefit figure to evidencing the true available amount and rebutting lifestyle assumptions, comes down to financial analysis the court can rely on under cross-examination.

If you’re defending a confiscation order, or advising a client facing one, the earlier that analysis begins, the more time there is to test the figures. Instructing solicitors can get in touch by filling in our contact form. Alternatively, call 0161 243 0595 to discuss your case with Rob directly.

Disclaimer: this article is for information and does not constitute legal advice.